Ongoing Debate: Should Grocery Stores Be Allowed to Sell Wine?

Should New Yorkers be allowed to purchase wine at grocery stores? This question is igniting a fierce debate in Albany, particularly among small liquor store owners who claim such a change could be detrimental to their businesses.

At Butler’s Wine and Spirits in the Town of Tonawanda, general manager Maddie Butler expresses her concerns, highlighting the historical significance of her family-run store, established 80 years ago. "If this passes, it would shutter probably 80% of all local liquor stores in the state," Butler warns, asserting that most liquor stores in New York are small businesses dependent on their local clientele.

Proponents of the proposed legislation argue that allowing grocery stores to sell wine would enhance customer convenience and modernize alcohol sales. A recent Siena College poll reveals that 75% of New Yorkers favor the inclusion of wine in grocery stores, and 80% of wine drinkers claim they would continue shopping at their local liquor outlets even if that law is enacted.

Supporting the legislation, Paul Zuber, Executive Vice President of the Business Council of New York State, highlights the need for modernization, stating, "We’re still stuck in 1934. Let’s open up more access for our New York State wines. Let’s create more economic development."

In response to the controversy, State Senator George Borrello is proposing a compromise, suggesting that grocery stores be permitted to sell only New York wines, thereby supporting local wineries without significantly harming independent liquor stores. "That would give a boost to New York wineries and grape growers, without doing as much damage to independent liquor stores," he explains, advocating for this fair compromise as the idea of sold wine becomes increasingly popular.

While some shoppers like Joe Beaumont remain loyal to their local liquor stores, arguing that “wine has always been in liquor stores,” others recognize the convenience factor. However, Butler emphasizes that the potential loss of small family businesses outweighs these conveniences, urging legislators and shoppers to consider the broader implications of such a law.

As discussions continue in Albany, local store owners like Butler are closely monitoring the situation, advocating for their survival in a changing marketplace.

About the Author: Chris Lehoux

Meet Chris Lehoux, an experienced wine connoisseur and dedicated blogger with a deep passion for all things wine-related. With years of expertise in the industry, Chris shares insightful wine reviews, valuable wine tasting tips, expert pairing advice, and captivating tales of vineyard visits. Join Chris on a journey through the world of wine, where every sip is an adventure waiting to be savored!